Males
Pelizaeus-Merzbacher disease (PMD) and X-linked spastic paraplegia 2 (SPG2) are at opposite ends of a clinical spectrum of disease caused by pathogenic variants in PLP1, which results in defective central nervous system (CNS) myelination. PMD and SPG2 have been observed in different males within the same family [Hodes et al 1993, Sistermans et al 1998].
Boulloche & Aicardi [1986], Hodes et al [1993], and Cailloux et al [2000] have summarized the clinical features of their series of individuals with PMD. The phenotypes in this spectrum cannot be neatly categorized into distinct syndromes but are summarized using designations frequently encountered in the medical literature (Table 2).
Table 2.
Spectrum of PLP1 Disorders
View in own window
Phenotype | Age of Onset | Neurologic Findings | Ambulation | Speech | Age at Death |
---|
Severe "connatal" PMD | Neonatal period | Nystagmus at birth; pharyngeal weakness; stridor; hypotonia; severe spasticity; ± seizures; cognitive impairment | Never achieved | Absent, but nonverbal communication & speech comprehension possible | Infancy to 3rd decade |
Classic PMD | 1st 5 yrs | Nystagmus in 1st 2 mos; initial hypotonia; spastic quadriparesis; ataxia titubation; ± dystonia, athetosis; cognitive impairment | W/assistance if achieved; lost in childhood/ adolescence | Usually present | 3rd-7th decade |
PLP1 null syndrome | 1st 5 yrs | No nystagmus; mild spastic quadriparesis; ataxia; peripheral neuropathy; mild-to-moderate cognitive impairment | Present | Present; usually worsens after adolescence | 5th-7th decade |
Complicated SPG (SPG2) & HEMS | 1st 5 yrs | Nystagmus; ataxia; autonomic dysfunction 1; spastic gait; little or no cognitive impairment | Present | Present | 4th-7th decade |
Uncomplicated SPG (SPG2) | Usually 1st 5 yrs; may be 3rd-4th decade | Autonomic dysfunction 1; spastic gait; normal cognition | Present | Present | Normal |
HEMS = hypomyelination of early myelinating structures; PMD = Pelizaeus-Merzbacher disease; SPG = spastic paraplegia
- 1.
Severe or "connatal" PMD is apparent at birth or in the first few weeks of life. Findings include pendular nystagmus, hypotonia, and stridor. Seizures may develop in affected infants, and motor deficits are severe (e.g., infants do not gain head control).
Later, children with severe PMD may have short stature and poor weight gain. Hypotonia later evolves into spasticity of the extremities that is usually quite severe. Children do not walk or develop effective use of the upper limbs. Verbal expression is severely limited, but comprehension may be significant. Swallowing difficulties may require feeding tube placement.
Affected children may die during infancy or childhood, usually of aspiration; with attentive care, they may live into the third decade or longer.
Classic PMD. Males with classic PMD usually develop nystagmus, which may not be recognized until several months of age; in rare cases, nystagmus does not develop. Affected children have hypotonia and develop titubation (tremor of the head and neck), ataxia, and spastic quadriparesis beginning in the first five years; they usually have some purposeful voluntary control of the arms. If acquired, ambulation usually requires assistive devices such as crutches or a walker; ambulation is generally lost as spasticity increases during later childhood or adolescence.
Cognitive abilities are impaired, but exceed those of the more severely affected children; language and speech usually develop. Extrapyramidal abnormalities, such as dystonic posturing and athetosis, may occur.
Survival into the sixth or seventh decade has been observed.
A transitional form, intermediate in onset and severity to the connatal and classic forms of PMD, has also been defined.
PLP1 null syndrome is distinguished by the absence of nystagmus and the presence of relatively mild spastic quadriparesis that mostly affects the legs, with ataxia and mild multifocal demyelinating peripheral neuropathy. Those with the PLP1 null syndrome generally ambulate better than those with classic PMD but may progress more rapidly because of degeneration of axons, inferred on the basis of magnetic resonance spectroscopy, which demonstrates reduced levels of white matter N-acetyl aspartate [Garbern et al 2002].
Complicated spastic paraparesis (SPG2) and hypomyelination of early myelinating structures (HEMS) often include autonomic dysfunction (e.g., spastic urinary bladder), ataxia, and nystagmus. A clear distinction cannot be drawn on objective criteria between complicated spastic paraplegia and relatively mild PMD (e.g., PLP1 null syndrome).
Pure spastic paraparesis (SPG2) does not, by definition, include other significant CNS signs, although autonomic dysfunction, such as spastic urinary bladder, may also occur. Life span is normal.
Males with SPG2 have reproduced; males with the PMD phenotype have not.
Neurophysiologic Studies
Visual, auditory, and somatosensory evoked potential testing show normal-to-near-normal latencies of the peripheral component of the respective sensory modality, but severely prolonged or absent central latencies.
Except in families with PLP1 null alleles or pathogenic variants affecting the PLP1-specific region or some splice site variants [Shy et al 2003, Vaurs-Barrière et al 2003], peripheral nerve conduction studies are normal. When peripheral neuropathy is present, it is mild in comparison to the CNS disorder, and is characterized by mild slowing of conduction velocities that may be more pronounced across those regions of a limb susceptible to compression, such as the wrist and elbow.
Heterozygous Females
Women with a PLP1 pathogenic variant may or may not have symptoms. Several investigators have observed that in families with severely affected males, the heterozygous women are unlikely to have clinical manifestations of a PLP1 disorder, whereas in families with mildly affected males, the heterozygous women are more likely to have symptoms [Keogh et al 2017]. Thus, an inverse relationship exists between the severity of manifestations in males and the likelihood of heterozygous females having neurologic signs.
The risk to heterozygous females of developing neurologic signs is greatest in families in which affected males have a PLP1 null syndrome, followed by those in which affected males have an SPG2 syndrome or HEMS [Hurst et al 2006]. The risk of developing neurologic signs is lowest in heterozygous females with a PLP1 duplication, who usually have favorably skewed X-chromosome inactivation [Woodward et al 2000].
The following explanation is offered:
Alleles associated with a severe
phenotype cause apoptosis (cell death) of oligodendrocytes (the cells that make myelin in the CNS) during early childhood. In
heterozygous females, the oligodendrocytes that express the mutated
PLP1 allele on the active X
chromosome undergo apoptosis early in life but are replaced over time by oligodendrocytes that express the normal
PLP1 allele on the active X chromosome. Thus, females who carry a severe
PLP1 pathogenic variant may develop neurologic signs because of skewed inactivation of the X chromosome with the normal
PLP1 allele (as with other
X-linked recessive disorders) or may have transient signs (while the oligodendrocytes expressing the mutated
PLP1 are still present) that abate as the degenerating oligodendrocytes are replaced by those expressing the normal
PLP1 allele [
Inoue et al 2001].
Alleles associated with a mild
phenotype in males do not cause apoptosis of oligodendrocytes. In
heterozygous females, abnormal oligodendrocytes persist and can cause neurologic signs [
Sivakumar et al 1999].
Hurst et al [2006] analyzed families with SPG2 or PMD and provided statistical support for the inverse correlation between the severity of phenotypes in affected males and their heterozygous relatives. These observations have important implications for genetic counseling and are discussed in Risk to Family Members, Sibs of a male proband.
Manifesting heterozygotes are usually not index cases, but rather are identified in the course of evaluating the relatives of an affected male.
Females with PMD have been described. This is thought to be due to unfavorable X inactivation in the brain [Scala et al 2019]. In some, there was considerable improvement of signs and symptoms after infancy. One female with classic PMD had an insertion of an extra copy of PLP1 at chromosome 1p36 [Masliah-Planchon et al 2015]. Additional complex chromosome rearrangements in females with PMD have been described [Ida et al 2003, Yiu et al 2009].